Neal wrote:Anything can 'count'. I refuse to see Fushed Away because of DreamWorks. Sure, it's partially Aardman but even so, Katzenberg supposedly did his best to influence this and his push to Americanize Aardman led to their eventual falling out.
About the only "Americanizing" the movie got was the standard Dreamworks Chase Scene, a few obligatory export gags about stereotyped Yankee tourists, and, keeping it even more to DW specifications...yes, ANOTHER danged tracking shot of the characters' funny city while "Funkytown" plays on the soundtrack. >_<
As required by law in any native DW movie, on pain of death.
Apart from that (and with their Katzenberg dues paid) it's allllll Aardman. Not W&G, maybe, but easily funnier than "Chicken Run", and miles ahead of "Robbie the Reindeer" under their own power.
The Wild = Disney. Pure and simple. They paid for it, they influenced the story. It <I>wasn't</I> a pick-up like Valiant. It's even counted in the classic Disney film list in the UK.
Hoodwinked actually elicited some pretty good laughs from our group, and that's usually enough to keep something out of a bottom-of-the-barrel "Worst" list for me.
And Prince of Egypt? Truly among the worst stuff one can see? Oooooo-kay...
Don't worry...I don't think you're "missing" anything else major, though they did have story input on Valiant and by sheer distribution fees they helped pay for it.
Put it this way, Valiant was a Disney Pictures presentation of a Vanguard Animation film. The Wild was a Disney picture animated by CORE, not a CORE "production".
Hm. I guess I can see why it could be considered canon in some countires, then. I mean... the opening to Enchanted was outsourced, as well. It's not exclusive in its outside-of -Disney-studios work.
Feature Animation Favorites:
Tekkonkinkreet, Watership Down, A Town Called Panic, Howl's Moving Castle, Rio 2096, Mind Game, Fantastic Planet
No. I actually don't agree with any CG content in the "classics" list. In my world, we'd jump from Home On The Range to The Princess And The Frog and either lump the Disney CGs in with the Pixars or - more appropriately - consider them "sideline" feature animation projects such as The Reluctant Dragon, Vistory Through Air Power, Song Of The South, Mary Poppins, Bedknobs, Roger Rabbit and the like. Disney, but not Disney, if you will. Kind of like how Dinosaur was treated...a Disney animated film but not part of the classic line up.
It's only recently that that film has been "let in" to the list, and while those films were made by the same teams, they're not "classically" animated films. I would, however, be fine with The Wild being a part of this "alternate" hybrid/CG grouping.