Barnyard
I agree. Like in Cars (even though that film's look is MUUUUUUCH better than BY) There has to be somewhat of a believable world, even if the rules are different. You can't just turn everything on its head and say: "Oh, it's a cartoon." (IMO) Where does that leave the audience?But STILL!
In Cars there are no humans....which doesn't form a believable world. In Monsters Inc at least there were rules about the Monster/Human relations: Monsters exist to scare kids and get energy from the screams. In Toy Story: Toys look like regular toys except when humans are around, and come to life when no one's looking.
In Cars:
1.) Why do the Cars exist?
2.) Who built the Cars?
3.) Why aren't humans aware of the "All-Cars" world?
4.) Who fixes the Cars when they get broken? Can they "die"?
And in BY it seems like all "rules" have been thrown to the winds. The cows can talk and stand up when they feel like it, the males have udders--it doesn't seem like a lot of thought went into this.
BTW that whole Cow-standing- up-on two-legs thing reminds me of that cartoon Cow and Chicken.
You can’t just have your characters announce how they feel! That makes me feel angry!
I guess stuff like that just doesn't bother me. You watch spongebob and they're underwater, and yet there's water UNDER the water, in bathtubs, through tears, etc etc.
So whatever "rules" you claim there are, don't matter to me. The cars thing. They're just... there. I'm sure they'll show explinations with that kind of thing during the movie, but all in all... okay so there's no humans. So what? Maybe they fix each other? Or not? Either way, it doesn't matter to me.
I've yet to see this barnyard trailer besides the teaser, so if there's a longer one, please direct me. But cows talking and standing up when they feel like it, while males have udders... anyone ever read The Far Side?
So whatever "rules" you claim there are, don't matter to me. The cars thing. They're just... there. I'm sure they'll show explinations with that kind of thing during the movie, but all in all... okay so there's no humans. So what? Maybe they fix each other? Or not? Either way, it doesn't matter to me.
I've yet to see this barnyard trailer besides the teaser, so if there's a longer one, please direct me. But cows talking and standing up when they feel like it, while males have udders... anyone ever read The Far Side?
What about Robots?ShyViolet wrote:[ In Cars there are no humans....which doesn't form a believable world. In Monsters Inc at least there were rules about the Monster/Human relations: Monsters exist to scare kids and get energy from the screams. In Toy Story: Toys look like regular toys except when humans are around, and come to life when no one's looking.
I think Robots suffered from the same lack of logic which hurt the film. If humans had been in it or there was some kind of explanation, the film might have gotten better reviews.What about Robots?
Great, now my vacation plans are ruined!Robots wasn't a real place?
BUMMER!
I see your point but...a TV show are a comic strip is different from a movie IMO. A movie is two hours out of your life, you're paying for it and it's there responsiblity to make the plot at least SEMI-logical.I guess stuff like that just doesn't bother me. You watch spongebob and they're underwater, and yet there's water UNDER the water, in bathtubs, through tears, etc etc.
You can’t just have your characters announce how they feel! That makes me feel angry!